feed back

PERSON ONE
Look at the CD cover front and back.
1) On a scale of 1 to 10, how aesthetically pleasing is the CD covers?
i would say an 8
2) How similar to real media products do you think our CD cover is?
it has a similar layout, but the images is very different, i think it has alot to do with the fish eye effect
3) What would you change about the CD cover?
if i had to say i would maybe chage the album title font
4) Would you associate this CD cover with other Cd covers in the same genre
(punk/ska)?
yes it has the same scense of originality
5) What do you like most about this product?
i particualy like the image and the facial expression of the singer
6) What do you dislike the most about this product?
im not shore if the parental advisory sticker is fitting
Look at the inserts.

1) Do you feel that the inserts compliment the CD cover?
yes they do, the images are alike
2) Do you feel that the inserts give more of an insight in to the individual band members' personality?
yes it helps you see there personalities
3) How similar to other media products do you think the inserts are?
i havent seem the use of a poloriod effect before, so no
4) On a scale of 1 to 10, how would you rate these inserts?
9
5) What would you change about the inserts?
maybe have more images, or lyrics to the songs
6) What is the best aspect of the inserts?
the trampoline pictures

Look at the Magazine advert.

1) On a scale of 1 to 10, how would you rate this advert?
8
2) How similar to other media products do you think the advert is?
the poster is different due to the size of the picture as they are normally not that big
3) Would you be influenced to by the product if you saw this mag ad?
if easily avalible yes
4) Does the advert link closely enough to the actual cd cover for you to recognise the CD after seeing the advert?
yes its quite obvious
5) Is the advert a good portrayal of the genre, does it link to other adverts which are advertising similar products?
i think so the image is quite powerfull
6) What is the best aspect of the ad?
i think the quote is quite funny
7) What would you change about the ad?
i would make the band website bigger so easier to see

Look at the Music Video.

1) On a scale of 1 to 10 how would you rate this video?
7/8
2) How similar to other media products do you think this music video is?
quite different, i havent seem a video where they have played in a public place
3) Would you be influenced to look at the band’s other material after seeing this video?
most probably
4) Does this video link closely to the other products in our package?
only to the one insert picture and the indentity of the singer
5) Does this video portray the genre well?
it show the fun in punk
6) What is the best aspect of the video?
the playing as the bus stop
7) What is the worst aspect of the video?
some of the shots are wobbily, and also someof the lip sincing is slightly out.

Look at all of the products as one package.

1) Do you think all the products link together and put across the same image?
yes i think so
2) What image do you think the band is trying to portray?
fun but serious at the same time
3) If you didn't know which genre the band were, what genre of music would you guess they played?
probably punk or rap
4) What kind of representations can you identify in the package?
i can see alot of representaion in the album name, fun and dont take themselves to seriously
5) Overall, what is the best aspect of the whole package?
i realy like the fish eye pictures
6) Overall, what is the worst aspect of the whole package?
some of the filming quality
7) On a scale of 1 to 10 how would you rate the whole package?
a good 8/10

PERSON TWO


Look at the CD cover front and back.

1) On a scale of 1 to 10, how aesthetically pleasing is the CD covers?
7
2) How similar to real media products do you think our CD cover is?
not very similar in my opinion
3) What would you change about the CD cover?
i think the picture might have looked better in cloour
4) Would you associate this CD cover with other Cd covers in the same genre (punk/ska)?
yes i think so
5) What do you like most about this product?
i like the band name font
6) What do you dislike the most about this product?
the back ground is a bit plain
Look at the inserts.

1) Do you feel that the inserts compliment the CD cover?
yeh i do
2) Do you feel that the inserts give more of an insight in to the individual band members'
personality?
maybe if there were a few more pictures
3) How similar to other media products do you think the inserts are?
not very
4) On a scale of 1 to 10, how would you rate these inserts?
8
5) What would you change about the inserts?
some written info would be nice
6) What is the best aspect of the inserts?
the poloriod effect
Look at the Magazine advert.

1) On a scale of 1 to 10, how would you rate this advert?
9
2) How similar to other media products do you think the advert is?
very different
3) Would you be influenced to by the product if you saw this mag ad?
yes
4) Does the advert link closely enough to the actual cd cover for you to recognise the CD after seeing the advert?
the image is very recogniseable
5) Is the advert a good portrayal of the genre, does it link to other adverts which are advertising
similar products?
im not fimiliar with the genre enough
6) What is the best aspect of the ad?
its very good as it has all the needed information
7) What would you change about the ad?
nothing i like it alot
Look at the Music Video.

1) On a scale of 1 to 10 how would you rate this video?
6/7
2) How similar to other media products do you think this music video is?
quite different
3) Would you be influenced to look at the band’s other material after seeing this video?
maybe but the film quality isnt great
4) Does this video link closely to the other products in our package?
it gives the same image
5) Does this video portray the genre well?
not shore
6) What is the best aspect of the video?
i realy like the shot through the wet window from the bus
7) What is the worst aspect of the video?
a bit uneven

Look at all of the products as one package.

1) Do you think all the products link together and put across the same image?
yes
2) What image do you think the band is trying to portray?
fun and dont take things to seriously
3) If you didn't know which genre the band were, what genre of music would you guess they played?
ska, rock
4) What kind of representations can you identify in the package?
they obviously dont like buses
5) Overall, what is the best aspect of the whole package?
the advert
6) Overall, what is the worst aspect of the whole package?
some mistakes in the video
7) On a scale of 1 to 10 how would you rate the whole package?
7/8